Not Engineers
PayPal's early team was not full of Stanford CS graduates.
Hoffman says they hired from unexpected places. Philosophy. Debate. Chess.
They wanted people who could think clearly under pressure. Not people who could code fastest.
Both Sides
The key test: could you argue both sides of an issue convincingly?
If you could only see one perspective, you were not flexible enough.
The ability to hold two opposing ideas simultaneously — that was the hiring bar.
We hired the best thinkers. Then taught them engineering.
The Results
Those unconventional hires became the PayPal Mafia.
Elon Musk. Peter Thiel. Reid Hoffman. Max Levchin. YouTube founders. Yelp founders.
The best talent pool in Silicon Valley history came from hiring for thinking, not credentials.